York Steak House: A Nostalgic Dining Experience with Hearty Steaks and Chicken Dinners

I was confused and delighted by my solo dining experience here as a 20-something. The food - my "York filets" were tender, cooked as ordered, and really hit the spot. The roll was warm and pillowy with a nice crust, quiet enjoyed it. Sides were all super bland, I was surprised that my "veggie medley" looked like it came straight from a microwave steam bag out of the frozen section. The only seasoning on your food will be from the S&P shakers on your table. I got chocolate cake for dessert, which was topped with stabilized whipped cream instead of icing. Didn't care for that or the sides! Ordering experience - Really confusing. I wish I had gone during a busier time so I could be queued into the expected flow of events. It's part counter service, part grab&go, part buffet, and part table service? The staff were very kind but I felt so silly repeating myself at every station "this is my first time here, what's going on? What do I do?" But it was really that bewildering to me! I will say I was entertained from start to finish, so much so that I almost forgot how hungry I had entered. And what I came for - the steak & baked potato - did not dissapoint. I wish I tried it out sooner! Definitely seems like THEE place to take your low-sodium grandparents out to eat.

Decided to check the York out for one thing only and that was the Chicken Noodles on Mashed Potatoes, green beans and dinner roll. The interior is like stepping back in time. The dark carpet, wood tables and dim lighting. The green beans were straight out of a can but okay. The Chicken and Noodles was phenomenal. Great big pieces of chicken mixed with homemade noodles in a nice thick gravy. Yummy!!!! And the dinner roll was off the chart. Pillowy soft and buttery tasting. Delicious!! On to my waitress, Michelle rocked it checking on me numerous times. I’m guessing she’s been there a while since she knew a lot of the customers. Definitely will have to make a return trip.

Food tastes great in the prices are very reasonable. It looks like 1970 in there. This is my new favorite place to go out to eat

Memories of the York Steak House glory days brought us in to give it a try. While some sites list this as a buffet, it isn’t. It has a one trip limit to only small garden salad items. Sign posted they were out of T-bones. Sirloin was pretty good. Service good. If you’re reading this, please hit Like

Two friends and I enjoyed our lunch today (01-13-26). I had the combo . I chose the 1/4 chicken and sirloin tips. Included salad, potato and roll. One friend had the 2-filets also came with salad, potato and roll. .My other friend had a cheeseburger. All three of us thought it was the best! Definitely will return. My chicken was nicely seasoned, my sirloin tips were so tender and juicy, topped with grilled onions. Normally I do not order sirloin, too tough. The sirloin tips I had today were so good. I will most likely order the same thing when I return! Great prices as well. The desserts looked yummy.

Place felt like it was stuck in a time capsule. Food was not very appealing or tasty. Service was good though.

It's cheap. That's a big reason for coming here. You won't leave hungry, but you will leave with some extra cash in your pocket. Its cafteria style. Salad and roll included with entree. They also offer chicken, spaghetti and fried fish. Steaks are pretty thin. Ribeye doesn't taste different from sirloin. Actually taste is just ok. But the service and the nostalgia are top notch. Pay for bottle water. The water they bring to the table is funky! Trust!

Wow this is now a classic the only one left! I love this restaurant! Me & my sister from another mister enjoyed our dinner! She brought me a peach pie, I tell you this pie was amazingly delicious! They get a lot of customers! I heard the pumpkin pie was number #1 ! Until I taste it I’m sticking with the !!!Will return soon!